>We had exactly the same problem. Our network guru decided the answer to >the 'why' was that it doesn't work. Thus our solution was to split the >mail server from TF server and place it behind a unix firewall....
The only "trick" is to restart Mail Server after making changes to "SMTP IPs.config". Well, you need to make the tab delimited format correct too.
When you have a range(s) of IP addresses defined in that file, Mail Server will only relay mail for mail coming from machines with those addresses.
"Relaying" in Mail Server means routing a message to the "default" gateway. Routing messages to the other gateways ( like Local BBS, TFNet gateways and so on ) is not considered relaying. They are considered to be local message delivery.